Nick Cohen at Standpoint explains, in regard to the way the global MSM entirely missed the story now exploding in revolution in the Moslem world:
…No news organisation in the West could base their main Middle Eastern bureau anywhere other than Israel, for the simple reason that it was the only free country with a free press, an independent judiciary and a constitution. Researchers and diplomats, as well as reporters, could phone or visit Palestinians in the occupied territories, as indeed could anyone else. Crucially, in an age dominated by images, television crews could get pictures. I am not saying that the authorities do not harass foreign or Israeli correspondents trying to report the undoubted violations of Palestinian rights, simply that they can report from Jerusalem but cannot from Damascus or Riyadh…
Add to it a bit of overt anti-Israel (if not pro-Palestinian) bias and the Palestinian’s increasingly savvy understanding of how to manipulate news stories in their favor and, presto!, you’ve got it. A decent, civilized, democratic nation beset by a host of enemies who would kill every Israeli if they could is cast as the villain. Meanwhile, the tyrants of the Moslem world – corrupt brutes, to a man – are let off…as are the Islamists who would stone a woman or a gay man to death at the drop of a hat. Not to mention the number of Christians brutalized and murdered over the years, the religious sites desecrated, the horrible fate which awaits anyone who dares to convert from Islam to another faith.
I’ve been saying for a long time – since pre-9/11, even – that no one really knows what the people of the Moslem world want. This is absolutely true and is easily demonstrated – without free elections to give an indication of where the people want to go there is no way to say, with certainty, that this or that action is opposed or supported by the Moslem people. No one – not the most learned and expert person on the area and its people – knows if Israel is really a bone of contention for the Moslem people. Perhaps it is true that the Moslem people want war to the death with Israel…but we won’t know until the Moslem people are allowed to vote in a series of multi-party, fair elections (just one vote doesn’t count…parties can win a lot of different ways, especially when it is the first time the people are really voting).
The only evidence we really have of Moslem attitudes towards Israel, the United States, the West in general and the Islamists is Iraq. There we have had several multi-party and reasonably fair elections. And here’s the thing – those groups who, perhaps, would want to make their main appeal on exterminating Jews or fighting the United States have not done well in the elections. For the most part, the people winning in Iraq tend to concentrate on bread and butter issues, along with security against foreign and domestic violence. I’m sure there are plenty of Iraqi politicians who rhetorically beat up on Israel, etc. on the stump…but in practical terms, there’s not too many votes in promising to send someone’s children off on suicide missions against Israel. Think for a moment, good people…do you really believe that Ahmed out there who’s got six kids to raise and is trying to rebuild his farm after years of oppression, war, revolution and civil war is hankernig to fight Israel? Would you be?
Just a bit of thought – and a bit of willingness to actually dig out the truth – will quickly explode the myths we have come to believe regarding that area of the world. In a word, we’ve been had. A lot of con artists (ours and theirs) have suckered us – even on the highest, official levels – in to believing a fairy tale about what has gone on and what will solve the problem. And here we’re just talking about how screwed up the debate is on Israel and Islam…we haven’t even got in to the way laziness and lies have messed up all other debates.
From global warming to abortion to gay marriage to energy policy and all down the line – all of our debates are deformed by incompetent and/or lazy reporting. It is easier to just show pictures, context be damned. Easier to quote an ignorant fool who has a shocking sound bite than to actually sift the evidence. It takes a lot of effort to really know what is going on – and a lot of humility to admit to ignorance. I don’t know about you, but I haven’t noticed too many hard working and humble MSMers of late.
The good news is that the New Media is stepping in to the breech. Because we have Drudge and Breitbart and blogs the truth is coming out…no one person or group having it all, but a diligent person can get a grasp of the situation by reading a variety of sources. This is why the old media is starting to fall apart – as the New Media digs up ever more of the truth, it is ever more clear that the old media reporting is often just a pack of lies. Some times not deliberate lies, but lies none the less. We have, I believe, a better informed population now than at any time in the last 100 years – we finally have reporting agencies who are fearless and willing to tell the truth regardless of consequences. And because of this we are developing the raw materials of rational policy.
Now, if we could just get a set of national political leaders who are as well informed as the people, we might actually get somewhere.
You must be logged in to post a comment.